First time trying this type of cookie and first time making them…super easy to make and super delicious!!! I made a few batches for an event and not a single one was left! Everyone loved them!! 

Did you double check that you used the correct amount of flour and butter? If so, you may try chilling the dough longer and see if that helps.

The best chewy cookie recipe I’ve ever found! I used salted caramel chips because it’s what I had on hand and that even worked.
So delicious that I’ll be adding them to my Christmas cookie baking list!!

It yields 42 cookies. The servings are listed right above the ingredients in the recipe card 🙂

Hi, Lisa! You don’t have to press them down, the cookies will spread in the oven as they bake.

Many thanks

Hi, Christine! I’m not familiar with jersey caramels, but they may melt and not work well for these cookies. You can use any other kind of mix in, like white chocolate chips, semi-sweet chocolate chips, chopped nuts, etc.